| Year | Pro Winner | Farm Winner |
|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Flyers | Hershey Bears |
| 2013 | Islanders | Hamilton Bulldogs |
| 2014 | Kings | Philadelphia Phantoms |
| 2015 | Golden Seals | Lake Erie Monsters |
| 2016 | Nordiques | Hamilton Bulldogs |
| 2017 | Canadiens | Worcester Sharks |
| 2018 | Nordiques | Peoria Riverman |
| 2019 | Canadiens | Philadelphia Phantoms |
| 2020 | Kings | Portland Pirates |